I adore this strange poem. It disturbs, yet... uplifts too?
One of my earliest memories is standing (rapt and terrified) next to a cow in bloat. Maybe four or five years old, I longed to run but I couldn't move. A medical emergency, bloat occurs when a cow overeats, the ingested feed ferments and excessive gas expands internally; it must be released or the cow will die quickly. But the men in that field that day (including my father) just paced and grimaced and stared. They seemed to be trying to decide something. I didn't know it at the time, but a veterinarian was on his way. What I recall most clearly was the cow's suffering—its frantic and unrelenting bawling—and although childhood me couldn't fully grasp the procedure and its intensity, finally, finally, finally someone arrived and I witnessed a puncturing and heard the gas release like a balloon deflating. The bawling ceased. The cow stood up.
I apologize for these images which are especially potent for animal-lovers, also for the poem which may be upsetting. But I share these words and this story, because no doubt this experience helped me learn compassion and empathy, key factors in shaping my neurobiology, my emotional intelligence...but something more too, something dark I continue to confront....
This formative event thrust me into a degree of discomfort I'd never experienced before and one I never wanted to experience again. Already an anxious and stressed child, this incident reinforced avoidance. Childhood me longed to ESCAPE and quite frankly, it became my default. I'm not proud of it, but I only have enough capacity to remain in the north field with those closest to me. I soooo admire people, those nurses, and doctors, and counsellors, the firefighters, the death doulas...but I am not a rescuer.
This is why I appreciate this poem—despite featuring a seemingly imminent death—Gilpin focuses on an alternative perspective, a less sober and severe inevitability—albeit temporary. The poem features no rescuer, just a cow and her calf in a cloudless field, alive. In this poem, I am not the farm boys seeking notoriety, nor the cow or her calf, but instead I relate to the poet.
Dear friends, I can't save you, and I'm sorry for that, but I will always want you to notice the stars.

Damn DB that was beautiful. It really touched me. and that cow I wouldn't be able to bear that sound. When I see animals and humans suffering, it lingers too long on me. It's heavy and I wish I didn't feel it all.
ReplyDeleteHeavy is absolutely the right word.
DeleteIt can be beneficial to let go of that child before it becomes a dark passenger. Rescuers run toward and cope by remembering those they rescued and not those they failed.
ReplyDeleteToo much introspection and self justification is unhealthy, even for those around you.
Sage advice, yet I know I will tend to remember those I failed.
DeleteWell you made me cry. Damn!
ReplyDeleteMy baby girl is a freak of nature too, beautiful and mysterious. I hope she notices the stars.
I hope so too. Yes, notice the beauty and the stars to cope with the mystery.
DeleteLaura Gilpin's poem always makes me cry. I see tragedy too clearly.
ReplyDeleteI think you're highlighting your insight and empathy and yes...it hurts.
Delete...Poetry Month, does the Golden Trash of Ogden Nash count?
ReplyDeleteHa, absolutely!
DeleteYou are a sensitive and humane man. I appreciate that. And that’s a brilliant connection with the poem btw.
ReplyDeleteThank you, sir! I'm more of a work in progress.
DeleteSad for the cow and the pain it went through but luckily relief was on its way.
ReplyDeleteBloat is terrible.
DeleteI loved this post, and like Pixie, I had tears in my eyes. I had never known about cow bloat before. When I was going through cancer treatments, I would frequently go for walks at night. For some reason, it helped clear my head. And I so remember looking up at the stars. It gave me a sort of peace I think. The quote "When it is dark, look for the stars" got me into the night walking routine and it helped center me.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing this; inevitable struggle means we all need some stars in our lives.
DeleteMy first thought on reading the poem was optimism...despite a grim prognosis the calf was able to see double the beauty in nature. Wonder what that says about me?
ReplyDeleteIt says growth mindset to me.
Delete"There are twice as many stars as usual." How profound and literally true. I like that a lot.
ReplyDeleteYour story reminds me of Hannibal Lecter's famous line. "Tell me, Clarice, have the lambs stopped screaming?"
Yikes. That is a good (and alarming) comparison.
DeleteI knew the cure for bloat from having read James Herriot's vet novels!
ReplyDeleteIsn't bloat awful?
DeleteI can appreciate the poem.
ReplyDeletePoems can be medicine.
DeleteIt's our human nature to avoid every kind of discomfort, isn't it. You're not alone there. -Kate
ReplyDeleteInsert fist bump here.
DeleteIt does make you think. My grandfather had a pet cow, a fine, certified, Jersey. Who relentlessly threw males. Farm stories take me back there, although my childhood was, um, protected from trauma.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you were more protected.
DeleteA poignant, reflective post, disturbing and beautiful both. You know, there are many ways to rescue. Not all are active. Sometimes presence alone is powerful. Acknowledgment. Acceptance. You may rescue without even knowing you’ve done so. Your ending reminds of that saying, “now that the barn has burned, we can see the stars.”
ReplyDeleteThere is much wisdom here. Thank you.
DeleteThis is such a beautiful post. I've never had much of an experience with such large farm animals. I didn't even know about the gas pains that cows can suffer. But the poem is looking toward beauty amidst difficulty. It really makes you reflect on life.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. It does invite us to look forward and inspires reflection too...a truly impactful poem.
DeleteBy the way, I did reply to your question about the web crawler. :-)
ReplyDeleteThank you. Insert fist bump here.
DeleteI posted this poem on my book blog a couple of years ago and it left me feeling sad yet hopeful. Life is fleeting for us all but there are moments of perfection.
ReplyDelete