Pages

Monday, February 28, 2022

No reason for it.

source
Ukraine was invaded around the same time I streamed Kenneth Branagh's film Belfast. Conflation tends toward error, but whatever fusion and alchemy I experienced continues to weigh on my heart and linger. Perhaps too, as a Gen Xer, Russian aggression feels a bit triggering, and absolutely deja vu. 

Set in 1969, the autobiographical film emphasizes Branagh's most formative "fork in the road" when his Protestant family grapples with deciding whether to stay in an increasingly dangerous and violent Northern Irelandthe only home they have ever knownor escape to Britain. Told from the perspective of Buddy, a composite of Branagh's childhood perspective, the film is like reexperiencing innocence lost. Pure time-travel, the story plots his early life in childhood fragments and memories and each squeezes the heart. It evoked my own parents and grandparents, young and vibrant againalso my childhood traditions, friends, and first crushes; it illustrated well that childhood confusion we all experience when the people we want to trust most make decisions, or are forced to make decisions, that will reverberate in our lives in expected and unexpected ways, forever. It is a universal story, told and retold. I was rapt. 

Likewise, I was glued to breaking news reports in Eastern Europe; I imagined those children in Ukraine, their slow-motion escape toward the border with Poland, compelled by fear, confusion, anger, disillusionment, many leaving their fathers behind. There is no reason for it. 

History has revealed that Northern Ireland's "troubles" are no longer so troubling. But what will history say about Ukraine and Russia, and the selfish ideology that enabled a conflict currently trending as WW3? No matter what the books written about this someday say, I have to ask again, when will we ever learn from history? Why must we repeat it? And what will our children remember? 

4 comments:

Debra She Who Seeks said...

When we wonder why people are as messed up as they are, the trauma of war (and intergenerational trauma of war) is, I believe, often at the bottom of it. Human greed and lust for power inflicts terrible wounds on the innocent and the bystanders.

jenny_o said...

I wonder where we will be in a month's time with this. Will Russia find a way to save face and back off? Putin is the definition of modern-day greed and ego. And you are so right - what about the children? I think many people have learned the lessons of history but the power-hungry never consider them.

DB Stewart said...

@DSWS 100%
@jenny_o Also 100% and I wonder too.

Molly said...

I hear you on the Gen X triggers too - those of us who remember the threat of nuclear war. We also had 'communism' thrown at us all the time, because ostensibly to be anti-apartheid was to be communist and therefore basically supporting nuclear armament and wishing the end of the world on us all. God we get told terrible things to justify terrible acts.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...